How many jobs do you lose to the contractor with more reviews?
You can't see the jobs you lose to a competitor with more reviews, because those customers never call you. If the company beside you on Google has 140 reviews and you have 9, the difference is rarely the work. They asked every customer and you did not.
You know the company. Their work is average and their trucks are nicer than their crews. They have 140 Google reviews and you have 9.
You do better work, and customers who have used both of you would agree. The trouble is the customer who has used neither of you and is deciding who to call.
You never hear from the jobs you lose this way
Someone searches for your trade in your town. Google shows three or four companies with star ratings and review counts next to each name. They tap the one with 140, and you never get a call you could have won.
There is nothing for you to notice afterward. No bid went out, so none was lost. The month just felt slow.
Mistake one: thinking good work brings reviews
It doesn't. A happy customer pays the invoice and goes back to their life. An unhappy one has a reason to go write something. If you leave it alone, your reviews will lean toward your worst days.
The company with 140 reviews asked 140 times, and probably a lot more than that.
Mistake two: asking only your favorites
It is tempting to ask the customers you know loved you and skip the rest. Google's policy says you can't pick and choose, and businesses have lost their profiles for it. Besides, a wall of perfect fives with nothing else reads as fake to a lot of people.
Mistake three: asking once, at the wrong moment
You mention it as you hand over the invoice. They say "sure" and mean it. Then dinner happens. One ask with no reminder gets you a review every now and then, which is how you end up with 9.
Mistake four: ignoring the ones you have
Read your own reviews page as a stranger would. If the last review is from two years ago and nobody ever replied to any of them, it looks like nobody is home.
What asking does
One hauling company we work with had 2 Google reviews. Four months later it had 46, and it took 25 calls from Google in that window. Their hauling was the same as before. What changed is that every customer got asked and reminded.
Questions to ask yourself
- How many customers did I serve last year, and how many reviews did I get?
- Who has the most reviews for my trade in my town? Are they better than me, or do they ask?
- When I hire someone, do I call the one with 9 reviews or the one with 140?
- When was my last review, and did anyone reply to it?
- Do I ask every customer, or only when I remember?